I Thought The Moon Spirit And The Ocean Spirit Were Gonna Be Katara And Sokka, And That Would’ve Made

I thought the moon spirit and the ocean spirit were gonna be Katara and Sokka, and that would’ve made ATLA even more interesting.

The spirits of the ocean and moon gave up their immortal forms to live on the earth. Why would they choose to be koi fish?

It would make much more sense for those spirits to take an avatar-like spirit form where they attach to different members of the Water Tribe. Always pushing and pulling at one another, of course the spirits would attach to a brother and sister.

Katara, being the water bender, would naturally be the moon spirit. Sokka would be the ocean spirit. But they had no idea.

So if they were the spirits instead of the koi fish, the story would’ve become much more layered.

And way darker.

When the Fire Nation invaded the Northern Water Tribe at the end of season 1, Admiral Zhao intended to kill the moon spirit. Let’s say somehow Zhao had figured out Katara was the moon spirit, and followed her north with Aang. So to kill the moon spirit, he would kill Katara.

After killing Katara, of course that would set off Aang’s avatar state and the water monster form.

Yue would still give up her life to bring back the moon, but she would be giving her life for Katara. This would absolutely destroy Sokka. First he loses his sister. Then the girl he loves gives her life for his sister.

After this, Sokka and Katara would simultaneously have a closer and more strained sibling bond. Sokka becomes even more protective to make sure he never loses Katara again. But he also resents her for being the reason he lost Yue. Katara would be wracked with guilt over this.

It becomes the source of tension between the two of them that builds throughout season 2 before coming to a head, where Sokka and Katara have a massive falling out. Katara says Sokka blames her for Yue’s death. Sokka admits it. They trade hurtful comments that cut deeper and deeper every time. While this is going down, they’re on a boat, and the waves surrounding them are getting more and more treacherous. They’re pushing and pulling at one another, just like the moon and sea. Then to save themselves, literally, they have to make amends to calm the sea around them.

It would’ve added so many more layers to their already complicated relationship.

It’s (to me) such an obvious choice to make Katara and Sokka the moon and ocean spirits, I feel like the writers HAD to have considered it! If they did, I get why they went a different direction. Having Katara die, even temporarily, never would’ve been allowed by Nickelodeon. ATLA is already pretty dark for a kid’s show.

If their target audience had been just a bit older, I truly think the writers could’ve run with that plotline.

More Posts from Scentedfoxwitch and Others

4 months ago

Happy gay fish month!

Happy Gay Fish Month!
3 years ago
There’s A New Recruit At The Shatterdome (and Zuko’s Not Too Happy About It)
There’s A New Recruit At The Shatterdome (and Zuko’s Not Too Happy About It)

There’s a new recruit at the Shatterdome (and Zuko’s not too happy about it)

Zukka pacrim au babyyy

Image id under the cut

[ID: two colored digital drawings of Sokka and Zuko from Avatar: the last airbender. Based on the scene from Pacific Rim where Raleigh and Mako first meet. In the first drawing Zuko is depicted from the shoulders up, frowning slightly and looking in front of him. It’s raining, and he’s holding a big black umbella and wearing a black coat. At the bottom a yellow text says “I imagined him differently.” In the second drawing Sokka is depicted from the shoulders up, looking at Zuko with an annoyed expression. He’s also holding a black umbrella, and wearing a gray coat with a white fur collar. The yellow caption at the bottom says “Hey, better or worse?” END ID]

3 years ago
And They Were Drift Compatible (oh My God They Were Drift Compatible)
And They Were Drift Compatible (oh My God They Were Drift Compatible)

And they were drift compatible (oh my god they were drift compatible)

Zukka pacrim au part 2 / part 1

Click for better quality!

1 year ago
👩‍❤️‍💋‍👩

👩‍❤️‍💋‍👩

3 months ago
Fin.
Fin.
Fin.
Fin.

Fin.

...

Beginning | Previous

(:

9 years ago
Suele Pasar.

Suele pasar.

9 years ago

CLUB MEDIA FEST EN MÉXICO

Bueno shabos les QUIERO contar algo hermoso para una fanaction si vienen los youtubers a Nuestro México lindo y querido, bueno es algo muy loco pero sería bueno que lo hiciéramos ¿no?

1.- COMPRAR UN BANDERA MEXICANA TAMAÑO “MURAL”, Bueno esto ¿como para que ? Pues en mi opinión sería muy Hermoso poner BIEN VENIDOS o GRACIAS POR TODO LOS AMAMOS y en toda la bandera los user de el FANDOM MEXICANO los que irían al evento y los que no llegaran a poder ir 💔

2.- IR AL AEROPUERTO Y COMPORTARSE, esto es algo muy importante yo QUIERO que disfruten su estadía en México y así ellos quieran regresar no es necesario empujarse para ver los digo los vamos a recibir no vamos a secuestrarlos esto es muy importante tanto para nosotros como para ellos.

3.- IR AL HOTEL Y LLEVARLES SERENATA, se que suena muy loco y a la vez estúpido pero imaginen todos llevamos de 20 o 10 pesos y van como unas 200 personas si juntamos y vamos por el mariachi LES decimos a los de seguridad que si los dejan asomarse tantito y PUUUM sorpresa SERENATA XD seria Hermoso ver su cara de ilusión ¿no?

4.- LLEVAR CORAZONES CON EL símbolo de youtube, esto de distintos colores algunos de Verde otros Morados 🌚 azules rojos o todos de un sólo color y cuando este apuntó de acabar el evento todos callarse y mostrar los CORAZONES

5.- EN LOS M&G DECIR QUE VENIMOS POR PARTE DE LOS QUE NO PUDIERON VENIR, esto por aquellos que no GANEN un M&G o que no irían al evento después todas las personas que tengan uno DECIRLES que les tenemos una sorpresa pero no decir cual

6.- REGALARLES UNA CANASTA DE DULCES MEXICANOS, no son caros y sería un gran detalle dar les muchos

7.- HACER UN CARPETA MUY GRANDE PARA METER CARLAS ESCRITAS A MANO O A COMPUTADORA DE TODOS EN EL FANDOM, haciendo esto vamos hacer un FANDOM muy unido y nos apoyaríamos entre todos

8.- LLEVAR LA MAYOR CANTIDAD DE SOMBREROS CHARROS O BIGOTES, esto principalmente por el mame y ver si son capaces de ponerse un sombrero charro y un bogotazo, cabe destacar que sólo los mexicanos podemos hacer estas cosas XD

9.- EN EL EVENTO COMO 10 MINUTOS ANTES DE QUE ACABE CALLARSE LEVANTAR LOS CORAZONES PONER LA BANDERA EN ALTO Y TODOS IR SE AGACHANDO, CUANDO TODOS ESTÉN ABAJO SUBIR DANDO UN BRINCO Y GRITAR “GRACIAS” sería muy emotivo ver su reacción o que algunos lloren de la emoción 💓

10.- CUANDO SE VALLAN DE MEXICO HACER LES UNA HERMOSA DESPEDIDA EN EL HOTEL, ¿como? No se pero algo sencillo pero con sentimiento.

Todos esto y muchas cosas más me gustaría que hiciéramos, digo que no sólo el FANDOM MEXICANO si no todos los países se vería el apoyo que nosotros les damos.

Me gustaría mucho saber que idea tienen USTEDES o que piensan de esto a mi me aria mucha ilusión hacer todo esto en el evento si es que se llegara hacer uno en México

Hay que dejar aún lado las diferencias y apoyarnos por que al fin y al cabo todo se haría con un simple fin y será el darles una de las mejores experiencia de sus vidas ¿no?

Att: 👑 Max 👑 Twitter: @xDMmarlenxD

1 year ago
Me When- Me When Kzosowimgayshdosdkajj

Me when- me when kzosowimgayshdosdkajj

6 years ago

“you won, and she chose you and she loved you and, sheS GOOOOOOOOONEEEEE”

Press play. do it. pls. I beg

  • thoughtsfrom1985
    thoughtsfrom1985 liked this · 2 months ago
  • honkersbonkerss
    honkersbonkerss liked this · 2 months ago
  • steadymuffinroadshepherd
    steadymuffinroadshepherd liked this · 3 months ago
  • sp1445
    sp1445 liked this · 3 months ago
  • kirarahu
    kirarahu liked this · 4 months ago
  • noidea1029
    noidea1029 liked this · 6 months ago
  • i-put-the-bi-in-dumb-bitch
    i-put-the-bi-in-dumb-bitch reblogged this · 8 months ago
  • i-put-the-bi-in-dumb-bitch
    i-put-the-bi-in-dumb-bitch liked this · 8 months ago
  • shyangelcreator
    shyangelcreator liked this · 8 months ago
  • stinkysarai
    stinkysarai liked this · 9 months ago
  • zaimore
    zaimore liked this · 9 months ago
  • kidstrong
    kidstrong liked this · 9 months ago
  • shanks2014
    shanks2014 reblogged this · 9 months ago
  • shanks2014
    shanks2014 liked this · 10 months ago
  • reputationtv2025
    reputationtv2025 liked this · 1 year ago
  • d8n-d8n
    d8n-d8n liked this · 1 year ago
  • wordwelder
    wordwelder reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • wordwelder
    wordwelder liked this · 1 year ago
  • ramblesrecs
    ramblesrecs reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • reduviidaegirl
    reduviidaegirl liked this · 1 year ago
  • daemosdaen
    daemosdaen reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • cooking-with-hailstones
    cooking-with-hailstones reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • cooking-with-hailstones
    cooking-with-hailstones liked this · 1 year ago
  • emma2980-blog
    emma2980-blog liked this · 1 year ago
  • nicosssbrainrot
    nicosssbrainrot liked this · 1 year ago
  • e-boybutnotreally
    e-boybutnotreally liked this · 1 year ago
  • lavander18
    lavander18 liked this · 1 year ago
  • beautifulpatrolwitch
    beautifulpatrolwitch liked this · 1 year ago
  • sn00zxie
    sn00zxie liked this · 1 year ago
  • katarasmomsnecklace
    katarasmomsnecklace liked this · 1 year ago
  • mxhsvsgx
    mxhsvsgx liked this · 1 year ago
  • thesilenceofthepoet
    thesilenceofthepoet liked this · 1 year ago
  • halfling-myth-lady
    halfling-myth-lady liked this · 1 year ago
  • scentedfoxwitch
    scentedfoxwitch reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • scentedfoxwitch
    scentedfoxwitch liked this · 1 year ago
  • lydiaofwhiterun
    lydiaofwhiterun liked this · 1 year ago
  • mangolemonjuice
    mangolemonjuice liked this · 1 year ago
  • ladyrijus
    ladyrijus liked this · 1 year ago
  • chimeratoonz
    chimeratoonz liked this · 1 year ago
  • laurasixthemusical
    laurasixthemusical liked this · 1 year ago
  • chocolatechipcheesecake
    chocolatechipcheesecake liked this · 1 year ago
  • oa-trance
    oa-trance liked this · 1 year ago
  • sees-writes
    sees-writes liked this · 1 year ago
  • luitennentsunshine
    luitennentsunshine liked this · 1 year ago
  • manicgarbagefire
    manicgarbagefire liked this · 1 year ago
  • 16idk
    16idk liked this · 1 year ago
  • spamish-inquisition
    spamish-inquisition liked this · 1 year ago
  • deanscowboyk-nk
    deanscowboyk-nk liked this · 1 year ago
  • wagadoogy666
    wagadoogy666 liked this · 1 year ago
  • blah-blah-blah-bla
    blah-blah-blah-bla liked this · 1 year ago
scentedfoxwitch - HoliOli
HoliOli

159 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags